SH!T SHOW: Valentine's Edition

TUE // FEB 08 // 07:00PM

A comedic storytelling game show about the times that made us go, "OH, SH*T!"

Created and hosted by Neil D'Astolfo, SH!T SHOW is a comedic storytelling game show in which comedians, celebrities and everyday folx share their most embarrassing, sh*ttiest stories. "Everyone poops," as Taro Gomi's classic children's book reminds us, which means everyone has also pooped in less-than-ideal circumstances/places/their pants while on a packed Long Island Railroad train on Thanksgiving eve. No? Just Neil?


Alli Brown (Awkwafina is Nora from Queens)

Chris Cafero (Netflix's upcoming Inventing Anna)

Joseph Lymous (2021 JFL New Faces)

Ann Marie Yoo (Comedy Central)

Host Bio: Neil D’Astolfo (he/him) is a New York-based actor, comedian and writer. Neil is a series regular on Paramount Plus’ Emmy-nominated "Stephen Colbert Presents Tooning Out the News" and recurred as Anthony Fauci on Showtime’s "Our Cartoon President" (also executive produced by Stephen Colbert). Other TV credits include Comedy Central’s upcoming animated feature "Washingtonia," and Hulu’s "High Fidelity" and "The Path." Neil was a house performer at The Upright Citizens Brigade (UCB) from 2018-2020, where he performed on Maude Night (sketch) and created and hosted "Fruitcake" and "GayTube (But Not Porn)." Neil’s writing for film and television has been acknowledged by Film Independent and the Nashville Film Festival, and his solo show, Mister Miss America, will premiere off-Broadway in Summer 2022. He holds an MFA from Columbia University and is an adjunct professor at Pace University.


Doors 6:30 PM, show 7:00 PM.
Tickets $15 in advance, $20 at the door, $5 livestream.


No outside food or drink is allowed.

Livestream ticket information

If you purchase a livestream ticket, Eventbrite will automatically email you a private YouTube link to the stream on the day of the show. If you have not received the private link by the show start time, please contact us for the link.


As we re-open we're doing everything we can to keep our audience, performers, and staff safe and are complying with all Covid regulations.

As part of this, all attendees must present proof of full vaccination to enter. Proof can be via the New York State Excelsior pass, a physical copy of the CDC card, a photo of your CDC card, or other electronic record of vaccination includes name and date (e.g., some chain pharmacies have an app with this information). In all cases the name must match that on your photo ID.

Our full Covid policies can be found here.


Tickets may be refunded up to 24 hours before the event. Within 24 hours we may take exchanges for other events at our discretion. No refunds after the event.


21 A Clinton Street, Manhattan